Skip to main content

'Innovative' Community Management in Ethiopia

Rural water provision in Ethiopia is based on the ‘Community management’ model which as the name suggests, is centred on the views and operations of the community (Adank et al 2013). As I discussed in previous posts, the community needs to be carefully considered when it comes to implementing any water and development projects due to their role in actually maintaining the project, which will determine its success. However while this provides a good theoretical base, the practice of Community Management of water resources in rural Ethiopia shows how this approach isn't always effective.

Chambers was a key first advocate of the community approach,  through his 1983 work 'Rural Development: Putting the Last first'. This book focused on the importance of highlighting the needs of those usually marginalised through a bottom-up approach. The community approach should be more than just abandoning a top-down approach by adding participation; it is more about user ownership and control.

The book 'Achieving Water Security: Lessons from research in water supply, sanitation and hygiene in Ethiopia' has explored the issues and innovations surrounding community management. The chapter this post will be centred around is on the 'Innovative approaches' to solving the shortcomings of the conventional community management approach.

The early 1990s signalled a change in Ethiopia, the end of the Military government led to great decentralisation, with responsibilities down to the regional level. The community based multi-sector project in Amhara in 1994 was one of the first community management projects implemented in Ethiopia (Behailu et al 2015). This developed into the 'Community-managed project' (CMP), which is now implemented as one of the four main water and sanitation approaches across Ethiopia, and is favoured most by the government.

The focus on community based approaches on the global stage came about in the 'International Drinking water Supply and Sanitation decade'. This movement recognised the need for safe drinking water and sanitation as a vital part of the global health targets (WHO). It also signalled the move to more low cost and NGO led projects. Key to this approach is the training of communities in the maintenance of the water infrastructure they rely one, which in this case in rural Ethiopia is mainly boreholes. The issues include the lack of technical capacity of the villages as well as the dependency of the project on external volunteers. This led to the finding that 43% of the community managed projects were not functioning. The factors attributed to this failure to the limited capacity of WASHCO and the local government.

Image result for water management ethiopia

Adank et al (2013) argue that a more 'pluralistic approach' including Multiple-use water services (MUS) and self supply would help counter these issues. The MUS approach acknowledges that water is used for a variety of purposes, so seeks to improve the sustainability of water points through 'add-ons' which can be adapting domestic systems for irrigation uses and vice versa. Two communities in the Oromia Region took on this approach and both saw a substantial amount of money saved on health services due to the increased sanitation reducing diarrhoeal diseases.

Self-supply is another method proposed which encourages individuals to improve their own water sources, often through harvesting rainwater or a household well, and share with their neighbours which creates a small scale communal supply. This reduces the dependence on NGOs and governments for investment, it is also likely to increase sustainability due to the increased incentive to look after your own investments.

These solutions are an example of understanding the specific variation of water use that I discussed using the Thompson et al (2000) paper in a previous post. This shows how community based management can go beyond simply 'local participation' but also be tailored to the specific needs and capacities of that particular community. There are particular inequalities within the community, such as gender, which haven't been touched on in this chapter which need to be considered when planning these innovative tailored approaches; this is something I will elaborate on in a later post.

These approaches may be innovative but they are still constrained by the physical capacity of the environment. Focusing on those who are able to harvest enough rainwater to meet their water needs overlooks those in even greater need who lack both availability and access.

Comments

  1. Hi Jeannie, great post clearly identifying the different approaches to community water management.

    What approach do you think is the most sustainable for rural communities in regions such as Ethiopia?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Rhona, thanks for the comment. Throughout my blog I have argued for the need to fully understand the intricacies of water use and context of the community; therefore I feel I wouldn't be able to judge a single approach as most sustainable across all rural communities in regions such as Ethiopia. I do however maintain my support for the community based approach and believe that the 'innovative' add-ons, such as those discussed in this post, should be used in conjunction to this approach where/if most appropriate, depending on the specific community.

      Delete
  2. Hi Jeannie,

    You mention the self-supply approach for households to reduce reliance on NGOs and government supply. In what places has this worked best/worst and why? For instance, how effective has it been for households and communities in areas with high precipitation variability?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Ana-Lin

      Since the self supply method discussed in this post does include both rainwater harvesting and the use of groundwater it should be a well equipped method for adapting to precipitation variability due to the use of both surface and groundwater; having these diverse water sources allows self supply communities to be more resilient.

      Delete
  3. Hi Jeannie,

    As you have recognised, community-based approaches to development can be quite burdensome. There are some major disadvantages, including the fact: training of community members to partake in projects requires a vast number of man-hours; training does not mean community members will end up being equipped with the appropriate skills to assist community projects; and the approaches require an effective management structure.

    So, given these disadvantages, to what extent do you believe government or NGO expertise needs to be implemented in community-based management approaches?

    Robert

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Robert,

      I agree that training community members to achieve effective management is a huge task. In an ideal world I would say that government support should be the main input into these projects as it is the state's responsibility to provide adequate water and sanitation. However much of the reason behind the necessity of these community based approaches is down to the failure of the state to provide, therefore in these cases I believe NGO involvement is needed.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Slum politics and the private sector

In this post I would like to move away from the previous discussions of community based water and sanitation in this blog by addressing the agency of the community. The schemes I have discussed so far have gone by the assumption that a government or NGO intervenes in a community to set up a water and sanitation project, while consulting or handing over power to community members. I would like to challenge this assumption in this by looking at instances where the community itself has taken action to improve its own sanitation - I will be looking in particular at slum communities, a group whose agency, skills and knowledge are often overlooked in development discourses ( Thieme 2010) . Sanitation practices in informal settlements are different to the practices in the wider urban area it is situated in, therefore requires an even more fine contextual approach. Urban slums manage human waste predominantly through unlined pit latrines, which can become extreme widespread health hazards wh...

The Immigrant World Cup

It's coming home vs Go back home to your own country... World cup fever this summer has been at an all time high. The teams dominating are the usual European and South American powers, and one thing notable about them all is the diversity. The European teams have players originating from Africa in abundance, with England also having plenty with Caribbean roots, and the South American teams being strongly Afro-Latino. While this is clear to anyone who watches any matches, coming across the infographic below certainly put things into perspective. Aside from Iceland, all of the nations on this list have significantly larger immigrant proportions on their teams than in their nations, with France and Switzerland even having a clear majority of immigrant football players. These statistics can be interpreted in a few different ways, one being in celebration of the diversity of the national team, another can be touching on the irony that is summed up by Lukaku in his quote above. ...