In this post I would like to move away from the previous discussions of community based water and sanitation in this blog by addressing the agency of the community. The schemes I have discussed so far have gone by the assumption that a government or NGO intervenes in a community to set up a water and sanitation project, while consulting or handing over power to community members. I would like to challenge this assumption in this by looking at instances where the community itself has taken action to improve its own sanitation - I will be looking in particular at slum communities, a group whose agency, skills and knowledge are often overlooked in development discourses (Thieme 2010).
Sanitation practices in informal settlements are different to the practices in the wider urban area it is situated in, therefore requires an even more fine contextual approach. Urban slums manage human waste predominantly through unlined pit latrines, which can become extreme widespread health hazards when flooded, and flying toilets (Katukiza et al 2012). The poor accessibility, lack of legal recognition and low resident incentive to invest, are the main challenges to sanitation projects in the slum.
Two years ago in the Nairobi slum of Mukuru, hundreds of female residents rose in protest towards the government over their lack of sanitation and land rights (Anderson 2014). This was following the lawsuits filed the year before which were not responded to. Sanitation in the slum is especially contested as there is conflict over whether governments feel that slum dwellers have a right to sanitation and land rights, due to the the fact they are squatting illegally. The Kenyan NGO Akiba Mashinani Trust believe that sanitation in the slum is important due to the inhabitants working and operating in the city and interacting with the other citizens. Sanitation can not be provided in isolation or only to elites, for the real benefits of sanitation to be reaped, it must be implemented and improved on a wide scale.

Mukuru is an example of another actor involved in sanitation that I have not touched on in this blog - entrepreneurs. The Kenyan social enterprise company Sanergy has transformed the issues of 'flying toilets' into a business opportunity. They build toilets and sell toilets to the locals and use the toilet waste to make fertiliser; they are in the process of developing their waste processing to include a bio-gas chamber to produce electricity (Chonghaile 2012). The co-founder has argued in favour of this private company approach to sanitation, stating that the economic burden of sanitation is often so great for the government that is it more productive for the private sector to look at it as an investment opportunity. A similar project includes the Swedish social enterprise 'Peeopoople' which is a self sanitising and biodegradable toilet which converts waste into fertiliser (Thieme 2010).
Slum communities can provide 'entry points for various enterprise-led developments' (Thieme 2013). One example of this is the micro-franchise 'Community Cleaning Services' (CCS) in Nairobi. Informal settlements are full of an untapped labour source with a huge potential that is often ignored due to the 'informal' label. This project acts as a response to the lack of basic infrastructure provided by the state, due to the governments extreme absence in these informal areas. The cleaning services the CCS provide are high quality and beneficial to health, but even the relatively low price is too expensive for many residents. This is where it is important to stress the value of health, and hygiene education is important.
There has been critique against this collaboration of the urban poor and corporate-led social enterprises due to accusations of romaticising the poor into 'enterprising subjects', as well as corporations receiving a demonising reputation within development (Thieme 2013). However the clear absence of the state within informal settlements, often due to their reluctance to condone the slums, means that the private sector is one of the few viable partners with the local community to make sanitation a reality. The rapid growth of the slum, mainly due to the high surge of rural to urban migration, mean that many of these small sanitation projects do not have a greater effect. While a wide scale, integrated approach would seem the only way to successfully solve such a severe sanitation crisis, without the government, this is incredibly unlikely. Patchwork solutions to sanitation in the slum, implemented by residents who know and understand the context, appear to the the only viable approach at this time.
Sanitation practices in informal settlements are different to the practices in the wider urban area it is situated in, therefore requires an even more fine contextual approach. Urban slums manage human waste predominantly through unlined pit latrines, which can become extreme widespread health hazards when flooded, and flying toilets (Katukiza et al 2012). The poor accessibility, lack of legal recognition and low resident incentive to invest, are the main challenges to sanitation projects in the slum.
Two years ago in the Nairobi slum of Mukuru, hundreds of female residents rose in protest towards the government over their lack of sanitation and land rights (Anderson 2014). This was following the lawsuits filed the year before which were not responded to. Sanitation in the slum is especially contested as there is conflict over whether governments feel that slum dwellers have a right to sanitation and land rights, due to the the fact they are squatting illegally. The Kenyan NGO Akiba Mashinani Trust believe that sanitation in the slum is important due to the inhabitants working and operating in the city and interacting with the other citizens. Sanitation can not be provided in isolation or only to elites, for the real benefits of sanitation to be reaped, it must be implemented and improved on a wide scale.

Mukuru is an example of another actor involved in sanitation that I have not touched on in this blog - entrepreneurs. The Kenyan social enterprise company Sanergy has transformed the issues of 'flying toilets' into a business opportunity. They build toilets and sell toilets to the locals and use the toilet waste to make fertiliser; they are in the process of developing their waste processing to include a bio-gas chamber to produce electricity (Chonghaile 2012). The co-founder has argued in favour of this private company approach to sanitation, stating that the economic burden of sanitation is often so great for the government that is it more productive for the private sector to look at it as an investment opportunity. A similar project includes the Swedish social enterprise 'Peeopoople' which is a self sanitising and biodegradable toilet which converts waste into fertiliser (Thieme 2010).
Video showing 'Sanergy' at work
Slum communities can provide 'entry points for various enterprise-led developments' (Thieme 2013). One example of this is the micro-franchise 'Community Cleaning Services' (CCS) in Nairobi. Informal settlements are full of an untapped labour source with a huge potential that is often ignored due to the 'informal' label. This project acts as a response to the lack of basic infrastructure provided by the state, due to the governments extreme absence in these informal areas. The cleaning services the CCS provide are high quality and beneficial to health, but even the relatively low price is too expensive for many residents. This is where it is important to stress the value of health, and hygiene education is important.
There has been critique against this collaboration of the urban poor and corporate-led social enterprises due to accusations of romaticising the poor into 'enterprising subjects', as well as corporations receiving a demonising reputation within development (Thieme 2013). However the clear absence of the state within informal settlements, often due to their reluctance to condone the slums, means that the private sector is one of the few viable partners with the local community to make sanitation a reality. The rapid growth of the slum, mainly due to the high surge of rural to urban migration, mean that many of these small sanitation projects do not have a greater effect. While a wide scale, integrated approach would seem the only way to successfully solve such a severe sanitation crisis, without the government, this is incredibly unlikely. Patchwork solutions to sanitation in the slum, implemented by residents who know and understand the context, appear to the the only viable approach at this time.
Hey Jeannie, have you considered the role of the urban poor in mobilising themselves to create alternative and innovative approaches to providing sanitation? A good example is 'The Alliance' of slum dwellers organisations in Indian slums who have come together to build their own community toilets, as they cannot rely on the politicians.
ReplyDeleteSome helpful readings:
Jewitt, S. 2011. Geographies of shit: Spatial and temporal variations in attitudes towards human waste. Progress in Human Geography 35, 608–626.
Burra, S., Patel, S. and Kerr, T., 2003. Community-designed, built and managed toilet blocks in Indian cities. Environment and Urbanization, 15(2), pp.11-32.
Hi Sristi, thanks for your suggestions, I have talked about the attitudes towards human waste in my earlier post on World Toilet day, I will definitely incorporate these other readings into my blog.
Delete