I have discussed the community based approach to water and sanitation throughout this blog, one important inequality dimension of the community I am yet to touch on is gender. I have stressed the need for a contextual approach when it comes to water and sanitation and gender is one dimension which cannot be ignored.
At it's most simplest level, the relationship between water and gender can be seen through the heavy burden of water collection on women and girls (Harris et al 2016). This leads to gender inequality due to women and girls having to spend more hours collecting water which could instead be spent in school or work. The 2010 WSP report on Gender and sanitation illustrates that women are at the heart of water collection and management in the household and suffer the most when sanitation is poor. Gender issues extend across sanitation through the problems which can arise from inadequate toilet facilities. Girls often drop out of school upon starting menstruation due to a lack of toilet facilities to accommodate this, alongside the taboos surrounding menstruation and cleanliness. An interview based study in south African schools by Abrahams et al (2006) revealed that in one case, there was only one flushing toilet with a available sanitary towel bin to serve hundreds of female students. This toilet constantly had long queues during breaks, leading to many girls taking days off while menstruating instead.
These initial issues amount to severe gender inequality. Water management is generally dominated by educated middle class men; even in poorer rural areas where a community management scheme may be implemented, power in decision making still lies with the community elite - men. This means despite the majority of water collection and maintenance being carried out by women, their opinions on management as well as female specific issues are not heard or addressed.
Once specific issue raised by Mahon and Fernandes (2010) is the need to address menstrual hygiene. While this article focuses on South Asia, the similar cultural taboos mean it is applicable also in the African context. The need for adequate clean water to wash sanitary cloths as well as privacy when washing is raised in this article, as well as the finding that menstrual hygiene is almost completely unmentioned in WASH policy, infrastructure, training or manuals. While there has been a big push for soap to be provided to poor communities, sanitary pads have not been included in this.
Once specific issue raised by Mahon and Fernandes (2010) is the need to address menstrual hygiene. While this article focuses on South Asia, the similar cultural taboos mean it is applicable also in the African context. The need for adequate clean water to wash sanitary cloths as well as privacy when washing is raised in this article, as well as the finding that menstrual hygiene is almost completely unmentioned in WASH policy, infrastructure, training or manuals. While there has been a big push for soap to be provided to poor communities, sanitary pads have not been included in this.
Gender based violence is the most troubling outcome of issues of sanitation. Many women and girls face violence and harassment when using public toilets or when practicing open defecation. As well as just the lack of private sanitation facilities for women, they also have to face the taboos surrounding menstruation and defecation. Abrahams et al (2006) investigates this issue further in the context of the school, illustrating how poor maintenance of toilets which often included broken doors, as well as their location often being in more secluded areas of the school, leading to a lack of privacy for girls and and increased fear for their safety.
Gender as an important dimension in development project has been recognised for some decades now, with Women In Development (WID) emerging in the 1970s in an attempt to cater to these female specific issues that are often ignored. This however was seen to be flawed due to its lack of attention to the root causes of inequality, this led the way for the Gender and Development (GAD) framework to attempt to address these flaws (Morna 2000).
Within the context of climate change, the UN has recognised greater need pay attention to the gendered issues; for the first time at the annual UN Climate Change conference 2016. This is due to the exasperation of gendered issues regarding water due to climate change, for example the increased variability of rainfall leading to more floods and more droughts has led to increased poverty. This has gendered effects due to poverty meaning education is prioritised for only male members of the family, and girls are often married off young to eliminate their dependence on the family. This conference has led to the creation of the 'Gender climate tracker' app which seeks to improve decision-making and government accountability through tracking women's participation in climate diplomacy.
Within the context of climate change, the UN has recognised greater need pay attention to the gendered issues; for the first time at the annual UN Climate Change conference 2016. This is due to the exasperation of gendered issues regarding water due to climate change, for example the increased variability of rainfall leading to more floods and more droughts has led to increased poverty. This has gendered effects due to poverty meaning education is prioritised for only male members of the family, and girls are often married off young to eliminate their dependence on the family. This conference has led to the creation of the 'Gender climate tracker' app which seeks to improve decision-making and government accountability through tracking women's participation in climate diplomacy.
WASH has made movements regarding gender equality by including women on their management committee. This however has led to, in some cases, increased violence and backlash against the women due to their adoption of what would be seen as a traditionally male role. The issue of gender in sanitation is a complex one and cannot be solved simply by putting more women on management boards, the taboos and practices must be studied in detail to successfully address this live threatening gender disparity.
This shows how the gendered issues from representation in management to lack of education and sexual violence are intertwined, and all need to be addressed.
Hi Jeannie. What do you think would be a good starting point for addressing the gender disparity when it comes to issues of sanitation and taboos surrounding menstruation and defecation?
ReplyDeleteHi Yuan, I think a good starting point for addressing the gender disparity and the taboos around menstruation and defecation would be greater representation and involvement of women on water management board. In it's most simplistic form, I believe women having an opportunity to voice their personal concerns and needs regarding menstruation, which is a controversial topic in many countries, that this would the the first step to breaking the taboo and producing more dialogue which can lead to tailored solutions.
Delete