At first glance it may seem simple to decide whether or not a particular area has adequate water and sanitation. If the area is served by a clean water source then it should have adequate sanitation - in theory.
Firstly we must clarify the disparity between water and sanitation. While clean water is needed for adequate drinking water and providing hygienic sewage disposal; just the provision of clean water doesn't mean that sanitation infrastructure and practices are in place to utilise this. Sanitation often lags behind clean water provision in poorer communities for this reason.
The main indicator of whether an area has access to clean water, as used by the WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme for Water supply and sanitation, is whether it is in proximity of a improved vs unimproved source. Only in 2013 was it proposed that water quality testing and risk management should be included (WHO/UNICEF JMP 2016). These new provisions are a step forward in measuring water sanitation through taking into account the actual quality of water as well as how the water supply may be inspected and managed.

The paper investigating Household water use in Ethiopia by Tucker et al (2014) exemplifies how the use of various water source, including unprotected and unimproved sources, mean that it shouldn't be assumed that an area has good sanitation simply because they are in proximity of a clean water source. This also links to the ineffectiveness of top down approaches, as the cultural context which may lead to the continued use of traditional water sources rather than improved ones, is ignored.
There are a multitude of complex factors that determine water use and this investigation shows that the particular water use which is neglected the most is often personal hygiene - this can lead to severe health issues which are a huge step back in the move to improved sanitation.
Firstly we must clarify the disparity between water and sanitation. While clean water is needed for adequate drinking water and providing hygienic sewage disposal; just the provision of clean water doesn't mean that sanitation infrastructure and practices are in place to utilise this. Sanitation often lags behind clean water provision in poorer communities for this reason.
The main indicator of whether an area has access to clean water, as used by the WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme for Water supply and sanitation, is whether it is in proximity of a improved vs unimproved source. Only in 2013 was it proposed that water quality testing and risk management should be included (WHO/UNICEF JMP 2016). These new provisions are a step forward in measuring water sanitation through taking into account the actual quality of water as well as how the water supply may be inspected and managed.
The paper investigating Household water use in Ethiopia by Tucker et al (2014) exemplifies how the use of various water source, including unprotected and unimproved sources, mean that it shouldn't be assumed that an area has good sanitation simply because they are in proximity of a clean water source. This also links to the ineffectiveness of top down approaches, as the cultural context which may lead to the continued use of traditional water sources rather than improved ones, is ignored.
The data collected across Ethopia led to the conclusion that genuine access to clean water sources
requires ‘continuous use of safe sources’, ‘exclusive use of improved sources’
and ‘sufficient volumes of water’ (Tucker et al 2014). That means in shorter
terms that if a study finds an area served by a single improved source, that
area only has adequate access to clean water if they use that single source only.
There are a multitude of complex factors that determine water use and this investigation shows that the particular water use which is neglected the most is often personal hygiene - this can lead to severe health issues which are a huge step back in the move to improved sanitation.
By conducting the study across various areas with different
livelihoods and a range of wealth groups, the paper was able to uncover the
factors that influenced water use. Most prominent determinants were wealth and
collection time, mainly due to labour constraints limiting the amount of water
which could be collected (Tucker et al 2014). If the collection time to the
improved source is increasingly high then sanitation levels will sharply
decline due to limited water being used for hygiene as well as more local unprotected
sources being used instead of the improved source which is more far away.
The WHO/UNICEF JMP has further acknowledged the need to diversify the data
collection focus across several types of water source by highlighting the need
to note whether water sources used were public or shared. Previously the Task
Force found they were overestimating the level of sanitation improvement by
disregarding the possible effects of shared and public water sources
(WHO/UNICEF JMP 2010).
There is another issue with looking at 'improved' sources when considering if there has been an improvement in sanitation. This is down to of one of the great misconceptions about water and sanitation. This is that water quality is the most important component in improving water sources and preventing disease, in particular diarrhoea. Studies in low-income nations however have shown that it is water quantity rather than quality which is more important in reaping health benefits (Cairncross 2003). This links in with the various water uses, as if more water is readily available, individuals are less likely to sacrifice what they consider as 'less vital' water uses such as washing hands and utensils. When water quality is good but less water is used, the water is rationed for drinking and cooking, therefore the hygiene side to sanitation is neglected. A study by Cairncross and Curtis found that washing hands with soap reduced the occurrence of diarrhoea by 43%.
This shows that hygiene interventions such as health education, and the encouragement of specific practices including handwashing, keeping animals separate and disposing human waste are just as valuable as the provision of clean water (Fewtrell et al 2005). The combination of installing an improved water source, as well as hygiene interventions is likely to be more successful than just one or the other.
I have discussed in this post the complexities surrounding water use and the inconsistency between water and sanitation; this therefore means that a singular water or sanitation solution cannot be successful on its own. Studies attempting to 'measure' or quantify water and sanitation need to take these complexities on board.
There is another issue with looking at 'improved' sources when considering if there has been an improvement in sanitation. This is down to of one of the great misconceptions about water and sanitation. This is that water quality is the most important component in improving water sources and preventing disease, in particular diarrhoea. Studies in low-income nations however have shown that it is water quantity rather than quality which is more important in reaping health benefits (Cairncross 2003). This links in with the various water uses, as if more water is readily available, individuals are less likely to sacrifice what they consider as 'less vital' water uses such as washing hands and utensils. When water quality is good but less water is used, the water is rationed for drinking and cooking, therefore the hygiene side to sanitation is neglected. A study by Cairncross and Curtis found that washing hands with soap reduced the occurrence of diarrhoea by 43%.
This shows that hygiene interventions such as health education, and the encouragement of specific practices including handwashing, keeping animals separate and disposing human waste are just as valuable as the provision of clean water (Fewtrell et al 2005). The combination of installing an improved water source, as well as hygiene interventions is likely to be more successful than just one or the other.
I have discussed in this post the complexities surrounding water use and the inconsistency between water and sanitation; this therefore means that a singular water or sanitation solution cannot be successful on its own. Studies attempting to 'measure' or quantify water and sanitation need to take these complexities on board.
This blog reviews well the evidence compiled by Tucker et al. in Ethiopia. One important critical comment is the apparent conflation of water and sanitation; the WHO JMP assesses both access to sanitation and access to safe water. It is quite common for someone to enjoy 'access to safe water' but not 'access to sanitation' as these are different facilities. indeed, as has been well demonstrated access to sanitation lags behind access to safe water in many low-income communities.
ReplyDeleteHi Richard, Thank you for your comment. I realise this distinction between access and sanitation was not made clear in my posts. I will definitely explore this difference in later blogs as well as the relationship between sanitation vs hygiene vs cleanliness as touched on in the most recent lecture.
DeleteHi Jeannie, informative post. People tend to use water and sanitation interchangeably, me included. I think there is a lot of fluff when it comes to these terminology, including the degrees of relativity. What is "improved", varies from country to country
ReplyDelete