Skip to main content

The issue with 'top-down' approaches

Development schemes across Africa, not just related to water & sanitation, tend to be centred on top-down approaches, imported from the West. There is a certain attitude in the development paradigm that methods imported from the Western world can be used as a 'one size fits all' solution across developing nations. This often ignores contextual factors leading to the 'development solution' actually creating it's own problems.

The classic response to the water and sanitation issues across Africa is the drilling of wells and boreholes.  The UN Joint Monitoring Program estimated that the failure rate for water projects in Africa is up to 30-60% (VossFoundation 2012). Despite the International Institute for Environmental and Development (IIED 2009) finding $360 million had been spent on building boreholes and wells across Africa, 50,000 of these were useless due to the lack of maintenance.

These poorly built and maintained water points can have severe effects on the community upon failure. One example is in the Katine sub county in Uganda, the water supply provided by a charity was a shallow well which was severely polluted by soil and faeces, this led to the African Medical and Research Foundation and Farm-Africa finding that worms present in the water was the cause of much of the local illnesses (Kelly 2009) .

Liberia is another example of an African nation whose top-down water projects failed. FACE Africa's evaluation of water projects in Liberia came to the conclusion that these failed due to the NGO's that originally built the water points not training the local community in maintenance. Other reasons for the community approach is the likelihood for the project to be more sustainable due to ownership and investment in the project meaning the community is more likely to want to maintain it. Carter et al (1999) argue that the initiators of water projects need to consider their impact and sustainability. Key components of a water projects potential impact can be ignored in top down projects; in particular understanding the actual benefits experienced by the users and consumers as well as a clear understanding of the existing water and sanitation problems. This is due to lack of understanding of the community and the contextual environment through the application of these generalised water solutions, rather than understanding the specific needs and limits of a community.

Voss Foundation took a participatory approach in Liberia, focused on community involvement and sustainability and claim they have received far more success with this in their follow up reports (VossFoundation 2012).These examples show it is clearly not enough for an NGO or government to simply drill several water points in a bid to increase water access statistics, to tick off the Millennium Development Goals. Local communities need to be at the centre of any development project, especially the provision of clean water which depends on infrastructure requiring consistent maintenance. The IIED suggest both training locals in the infrastructure maintenance as well as acknowledging the value of their existing contextual knowledge is necessary for a sustainable water project (IIED 2009).

The water engineer Bob Reed, co-author of 'Rural Water supply in Africa' in 2004, has debated the sustainability of the community based management approach, as well as controversially arguing that boreholes are no longer a beneficial rural water solution (Perkins 2008). He argues that external support from an institution or the government is required to maintain any rural water project in sub-Saharan Africa, as well as the low income of many of these rural communities meaning that they are unable to support a mechanic for maintenance.



The Development paradigm has seen a shift from top down to more community centred development because of the top down failures, the failures have been attributed to the inability of big government or foreign institutions being able to 'govern from a distance' meaning projects they may implement are likely to fail due to the lack of community control (Agrawal & Gibson 1999). The move towards the community based approach in sub Saharan Africa especially, has followed wider decentralisation trends of governance and the increased prominence of the NGO 'project approach' (Harvey and Reed 2006).

Harvey's dismissal of community management and boreholes must be taken with caution as shown by Upgro: Hidden crisis. This is a UK funded project that is dedicated to understanding the complex causes behind the various failed rural groundwater supplies. They state that there is little data or analysis around why many sources are non-functional, therefore laying blame on singular causes such as the inability for the community to maintain a borehole, could be inaccurate.

While the debate on community management is still ongoing, and there are strong advocates for each side, I maintain that a complete top down approach is unlikely to be successful due to various reasons that I have discussed in this post. While rural communities in sub-Saharan Africa may not have the finances or the resources to completely build and maintain a new improved water source, there does need to be some element of community participation for a project to last; as no matter how much financial and technical support is poured into a project, if it is not supported and accepted by the community, it will not be used by the community, therefore will have no effect.

Comments

  1. You raise a very important point about community involvement and 'buy-in' to development projects, particularly those addressing access to safe water. There is a new UK-funded project addressing the problem of borehole failure in several countries in Sub-Saharan Africa: https://upgro-hidden-crisis.org/

    ReplyDelete
  2. Very interesting read, but wouldn't you say getting NGOs to train locals is still essentially a top-down approach? In your opinion, how could dependency on external institutions be minimalised?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I suppose it is difficult to completely eliminate all institutional influence in any external development project, however if you refer to my later post on Innovative Community Management in Ethiopia, I describe the approach of 'self-supply'. This is one example of encouraging communities to invest and maintain their own water resources at a household level, which aims to make water resources more self dependent.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Slum politics and the private sector

In this post I would like to move away from the previous discussions of community based water and sanitation in this blog by addressing the agency of the community. The schemes I have discussed so far have gone by the assumption that a government or NGO intervenes in a community to set up a water and sanitation project, while consulting or handing over power to community members. I would like to challenge this assumption in this by looking at instances where the community itself has taken action to improve its own sanitation - I will be looking in particular at slum communities, a group whose agency, skills and knowledge are often overlooked in development discourses ( Thieme 2010) . Sanitation practices in informal settlements are different to the practices in the wider urban area it is situated in, therefore requires an even more fine contextual approach. Urban slums manage human waste predominantly through unlined pit latrines, which can become extreme widespread health hazards wh...

The Immigrant World Cup

It's coming home vs Go back home to your own country... World cup fever this summer has been at an all time high. The teams dominating are the usual European and South American powers, and one thing notable about them all is the diversity. The European teams have players originating from Africa in abundance, with England also having plenty with Caribbean roots, and the South American teams being strongly Afro-Latino. While this is clear to anyone who watches any matches, coming across the infographic below certainly put things into perspective. Aside from Iceland, all of the nations on this list have significantly larger immigrant proportions on their teams than in their nations, with France and Switzerland even having a clear majority of immigrant football players. These statistics can be interpreted in a few different ways, one being in celebration of the diversity of the national team, another can be touching on the irony that is summed up by Lukaku in his quote above. ...

'Innovative' Community Management in Ethiopia

Rural water provision in Ethiopia is based on the ‘Community management’ model which as the name suggests, is centred on the views and operations of the community (Adank et al 2013) . As I discussed in previous posts, the community needs to be carefully considered when it comes to implementing any water and development projects due to their role in actually maintaining the project, which will determine its success. However while this provides a good theoretical base, the practice of Community Management of water resources in rural Ethiopia shows how this approach isn't always effective. Chambers was a key first advocate of the community approach,  through his 1983 work ' Rural Development: Putting the Last first' . This book focused on the importance of highlighting the needs of those usually marginalised through a bottom-up approach. The community approach should be more than just abandoning a top-down approach by adding participation; it is more about user ownership an...